Spine surgeons are increasingly being held responsible for outcomes shaped by decisions they have little control over.
From insurance-driven treatment delays and restrictions on surgical care to patient expectations and postoperative recovery, spine surgeons told Becker’s that accountability is expanding well beyond the operating room. Several warned that while insurers and health systems influence when and how patients receive care, surgeons are often left answering for the results.
Eight spine surgeons shared where they believe the gap between responsibility and control is growing widest.
Editor’s note: Responses have been lightly edited for clarity and length.
Quentin Durward, MD. Neurosurgeon at The Center for Neurosciences, Orthopaedics & Spine (Dakota Dunes, S.D.): The biggest hassle I’m having to deal with currently is pre-authorization. Each insurance company, Medicare, and Medicaid should be required by law to send out to surgeons a list of what the actual “trigger” words or phrases that must be included in a consult to “trigger” approval.
Vadim Goz, MD. Spine Surgeon in Reno, Nev.: Spine surgeons are increasingly held accountable for patient outcomes, yet many of the factors that determine those outcomes sit outside the operating room. Payer-driven prior authorization delays, restrictions on implant and facility choice and patient comorbidities all shape results in ways we cannot control. However, when the ultimate outcome of an intervention is suboptimal, the responsibility still lands on the surgeon.
Philip Louie, MD. Spine Surgeon at the University of Washington (Seattle): We’re accountable for the fusion. We’re also accountable, apparently, for the brother-in-law who asks the patient to help move a couch three weeks after surgery. But honestly, more and more, spine surgeons are judged by how patients rate their own recovery. Those ratings depend a lot on whether the patient understood their instructions, could get to physical therapy or can navigate a confusing healthcare system for various medical needs. Our risk adjustment doesn’t account for any of those.
Richard Menger, MD. Chief of Complex Spine Surgery, Vice Chair of Neurosurgery and Director of the USA Health Spine Institute at USA Health (Mobile, Ala.): Spine surgeons are increasingly held accountable for both the clinical outcome and the overall patient experience, yet we often don’t control the full care iteration. From prior authorization delays and implant availability to postoperative care pathways, facility constraints, and social factors that influence recovery, many of the variables that shape results sit outside the operating room. We remain responsible for the endpoint even when we lack authority over the process that gets us there.
James Mooney, MD. Complex and Minimally Invasive Spine Deformity Surgeon at Virginia Commonwealth University (Richmond): Spine surgeons are increasingly held accountable for timely recovery while having limited control over when insurers allow treatment to begin. We can establish a diagnosis, recommend appropriate care and advocate for approval, but we cannot control authorization timelines or coverage decisions.
When insurance requirements unnecessarily delay appropriate treatment, patients bear the consequences through prolonged pain, disability and frustration. Yet the surgeon remains the face of their care and is often left explaining decisions made elsewhere.
Accountability should extend to every organization making decisions that affect access to care.
Ramin Raiszadeh, MD. Orthopedic Spine Surgeon at Spine and Brain Institute of San Diego: Surgeons are held accountable for outcomes and patient satisfaction, but insurers increasingly decide when and whether a patient gets surgery. The peer to peer process is deeply flawed; denial has become the default answer to appropriate surgical care, often from a reviewer with no spine expertise. The patient suffers while waiting, a straightforward case becomes a more complex one, outcomes are worse and costs go up for the patient and the entire system. Yet the surgeon still owns the result.
Lali Sekhon, MD, PhD. Spine Surgeon at Reno (Nev.) Orthopedic Center: Poor outcomes in unhealthy patients. We are often referred obese, deconditioned, sarcopenic, osteoporotic or chronic pain patients with years of poor health and life choices who have unrealistic expectations and complications that ’normal’ patients would not have. They often come in extremis, many through the emergency room door, expecting the spine surgeon to miraculously fix everything and when things go south, it’s the surgeon’s fault.
Paul Vessa, MD. Orthopedic Spine Surgeon and Medical Director at New Jersey Spine Institute (Bedminster): The field of Spine Surgery, since the passage of the ACA in 2010, has changed dramatically. The ACA was designed to empower the health insurance industry by requiring coverage for most of the population, which has resulted in a considerable effect on the private practice of spine surgery. Prior authorization has created significant administrative obstacles for spine surgeons in private practice for which we have very little control. Office personnel have had to be hired to battle the health insurance cartel in order to get care and diagnostic tests, such as imaging and surgical procedures approved.
These significant obstacles delay care and dramatically impacts the throughput of patients in our practice.The amount of time and increased overhead now devoted to prior authorization presents a considerable challenge to efficiently run a private spine surgery practice. Additionally, the health insurance cartel will always claim that prior authorization is not a guarantee for proper reimbursement despite the time and manpower the authorization consumed. Care can be delayed weeks and even months as the prior authorization obstacles are navigated, which can have an impact on patient satisfaction and surgical results. To health insurance companies, timely and high quality reproducible care is always secondary to their profits. Raising premiums and denying and delaying care is a veritable printing press for the health insurance cartel. The longer they can hang on to premium dollars the higher their float can increase in value in the markets.
