Alpesh Patel, MD, says he doesn’t consider himself a fan of CMS’ latest round of cuts. But the Chicago-based Northwestern Medicine spine surgeon said they are doing something surgeons have struggled to do on their own: pushing health systems to invest in getting patients healthier before they reach the operating room.
Dr. Patel co-authored a study published in the October issue of Clinical Spine Surgery with fellow Northwestern spine surgeon Wellington Hsu, MD, and colleagues. The team reviewed 618 patients who had elective spine surgery for degenerative conditions from 2013 to 2018. Forty-four of them, or 7.1%, visited the emergency department within 90 days of surgery.
Obesity, diabetes, congestive heart failure, a history of heart attack and opioid use before surgery were independent risk factors for an early ED visit. Those patients also used more care over the following year, including more MRIs, repeat ED visits, urgent care visits and opioid prescriptions. The authors recommended a sharper focus on optimizing patients’ health before surgery.
Pressure from every direction
The study lands as CMS tightens the screws on hospitals and surgeons alike. CMS is penalizing 2,334 hospitals, or about 80% of those the agency evaluated, for higher-than-expected readmissions in fiscal 2027. Those penalties took effect Oct. 1.
On the physician side, CMS’ final 2027 physician fee schedule, released Nov. 4, cuts the conversion factor by 2.31%, deeper than the 1.68% cut it proposed in July. The proposed rule had also threatened cuts of up to 20% for hip and knee replacements; the final rule softened that hit but still trims joint replacement and same-day care.
And starting Jan. 1, the mandatory Ambulatory Specialty Model will tie 3,319 low back pain clinicians’ Medicare Part B pay to their performance on quality and cost. The bonus or penalty applies to all of a physician’s Part B payments, not just low back pain care.
“They’re doing it in pretty extreme ways,” Dr. Patel told Becker’s. “If you look at physician payment cuts that are universal, you look at hip and knee replacement cuts that are massive. They’re doing it in really, I think, draconian or drastic ways. But they’re also doing it, I think, in understanding where pressure and economic leverage can get behavior change to occur faster than it would have in the past.”
A forcing function for health systems
Surgeons have talked about preoperative optimization for years, Dr. Patel said. What has been missing is change at scale, which largely runs through big health systems and large orthopedic groups. Penalties and pay cuts give those organizations an economic reason to build new workflows and services around perioperative care.
“No one’s excited about CMS cuts or CMS penalties. No one loves those,” he said. “But we kind of need to have some type of forcing function that makes everyone change their behavior at a larger scale. Like, I, as one surgeon, I can change my practice. That doesn’t put even a dent in improving the quality of surgical care at a population level.”
Once a CMS rule, a payer contract or public reporting puts weight on a health system, the change can reach 30, 40, 50 or 100 surgeons at once, he said. The economic argument often trails the clinical one, but it is the one that moves budgets.
Northwestern’s spine group has worked on quality for years, “CMS or not,” Dr. Patel said. The penalties now give the team a stronger case when it goes to the health system for resources.
“It’s not just to write papers. It’s not just to help patients,” he said. “It’s, hey, there’s a blueprint that we can potentially create if we get the resources to scale that.”
The study’s data runs through 2018, before much of spine’s shift to ASCs and same-day discharge. Dr. Patel said he doesn’t yet have data on whether that shift is sending more patients to the ED. He plans to ask his team to examine it, though he expects improvements in outpatient spine quality may wash out any effect.
What optimization looks like in practice
No program will prevent every readmission, Dr. Patel said. He pushed back on CMS’ “never events” label, noting that surgery involves complex physiology, anesthesia and emotions.
“We’re not building a car,” he said. “We’re trying to help people.”
For surgeons who feel they are doing everything right and still see readmissions, Dr. Patel said most likely have room to improve. Those who truly are doing it all should consider how much worse their numbers would be without that work, he said. Beyond cost, readmissions carry an emotional toll for patients and surgeons and a reputational risk for practices.
The biggest step is looking beyond the surgeon, he said. At Northwestern, the optimization team includes anesthesiologists, hospital medicine physicians, spine nurses and physician assistants alongside surgeons. A surgeon in a small private practice may have only a PA, so that team has to be built within the ASC and the hospitals where they operate. Consistent communication is the first priority, because things fall through the cracks easily.
The second is honest, organized data. Each month, Northwestern’s 10-surgeon spine group reviews every readmission and reported complication. Each surgeon sees their own rates alongside the group’s, and the group sets annual targets. When a surgeon is an outlier, leaders sit down with them to figure out what support their practice needs.
“If it’s too centralized and too dictatorial, I don’t think we’ll get surgeons and their teams to buy in,” Dr. Patel said. Giving surgeons data and the tools to act on it builds longer-term buy-in, he said, and likely helps with surgeon retention too.
Getting hospitals to see what surgeons see
When Dr. Patel shared the study on LinkedIn, he said some readers responded that surgeons have known this forever. He doesn’t dispute that. The difference, he said, is that data on readmissions and complications carries more weight with the hospitals and practices surgeons work through, which may not fully understand what it takes to drive quality care.
That makes studies like this one a tool for surgeons who want to build an optimization program, or hire one in, and need to explain why it is worth the money.
“There’s clear evidence that this is in the best interest not just of the patient, the surgeon, but also the hospitals and the practices that we’re at,” he said. “How do we get the attention of the hospital systems onto the problem that we as surgeons see?”
