Orthopedic practices can have talented surgeons, strong patient volumes and a well-established reputation — and still unravel.
The failure point in most cases, according to surgeons, is not clinical. It is the leadership infrastructure around the physicians: how decisions get made, who is accountable for outcomes, whether hard conversations about money and succession happen before they become crises, and whether partners are aligned on where the practice is heading and why.
Five surgeons and leaders shared with Becker’s the leadership mistake they have seen most often derail a practice.
Ask Orthopedic Surgeons is a series of questions posed to orthopedic surgeons and leaders around the country about clinical, business and policy issues affecting orthopedic care. Becker’s invites all orthopedic surgeons and specialists to respond.
Next question: How are you thinking about the long-term viability of your ASC — as an investment, an operational asset, or both?
Please send responses to Cameron Cortigiano at ccortigiano@beckershealthcare.com by 5 p.m. Central time on Nov. 23.
Note: Responses were lightly edited for clarity and length.
Question: What is one leadership mistake you’ve seen derail an otherwise strong orthopedic practice?
Joshua Alpert, MD. Orthopedic Surgeon of Fox Valley Orthopedics (Geneva, Ill.): One leadership mistake I’ve seen derail otherwise strong orthopedic practices is a lack of accountability. When leaders fail to own their decisions, communicate transparently, or take responsibility for outcomes, trust erodes quickly. The most effective leaders are willing to acknowledge challenges, address them openly, and hold themselves accountable while implementing solutions. Accountability and transparency are the foundation of a healthy culture and long-term success.
Kurt Hirshorn, MD. Orthopedic Surgeon at Florida Orthopedic Institute (St. Petersburg): A leadership mistake I’ve seen derail an otherwise strong orthopedic practice is when the leadership team loses sight of the surgeons and the patients and starts making decisions primarily around administration, revenue or growth. Orthopedics is a clinical business, and the people making decisions need to understand what actually happens in the operating room and in the clinic. If physicians feel that decisions are being made without understanding the realities of patient care, you quickly lose trust, morale and ultimately good physicians.
The other mistake is trying to standardize everything. Standardized pathways and protocols can improve efficiency, but orthopedic patients are not interchangeable. A straightforward primary knee replacement is very different from a complex revision, and the surgeon needs the ability to adjust the plan when the patient requires it. Good leadership should create structure, control unnecessary costs and hold people accountable, but it should empower the orthopedic surgeons with the authority to make sound clinical decisions.
Amit Jain, MD. Spine Surgeon and Vice President of Care Transformation at Johns Hopkins Medicine (Baltimore): Protecting senior surgeon productivity at the expense of aligning the entire group toward value, team culture, and mid-career succession. When leadership fails to bridge the gap between individual productivity and collective enterprise strategy, the practice invariably splinters.
Farzin Kabaei, MD. Orthopedic Surgeon at Docs Health (Los Angeles): Assuming that a great surgeon is automatically a great leader. They are different skills. A practice gets into trouble when the partners avoid hard conversations about money, call coverage and succession, and when nobody is clearly in charge of the business. Small resentments turn into departures, and one or two departures can take down a group. The strong practices I have seen put the governance in writing early, share the numbers openly with every partner and pick leaders for their ability to lead, not their case volume.
Alex Vaccaro, MD, PhD. President and Physician Partner at Rothman Orthopaedic Institute (Philadelphia): One of the most dangerous leadership errors for an orthopedic practice which has experienced continued success over time, is believing that success will continue indefinitely. Strong practices with successful histories have greater risk due to the “inertia” caused by success. As volume increases, surgeon availability decreases and the brand grows stronger; it is easier to defend the current model versus questioning it. However, our environment is constantly changing at a rapid pace. Our reimbursement models are decreasing, patient care continues to shift toward ambulatory care settings, payers are increasing their sophistication, private equity and health systems are continuing to consolidate, and technology is continuing to influence how patients obtain and interact with healthcare.
A leader’s failure is not just the speed at which they change. A leader’s failure is their inability to align physicians as to why changes need to occur. Physicians are typically resistant to new strategies that appear to diminish their autonomy, compensation, or the culture they developed. Imposing change on physicians from the top creates resistance. Avoiding making difficult choices creates even greater damage: Stagnation.
Therefore, for orthopedic practices that wish to maintain their entrepreneurial spirit (that was responsible for creating their success), yet recognize that the interests of the group cannot always be secondary to those of the individual, require physician involvement, transparency regarding financial decisions and compensation, and sometimes, difficult discussions about accountability, accessibility, growth, and investment.
In my experience, few orthopedic practices fail due to a lack of talent among their surgeons. The greatest risk lies within having talented individuals working against each other. Therefore, the single most important responsibility of a leader is not solely to manage the practice. A leader’s primary responsibility is to ensure continuous alignment exists among all members of the practice as to where the practice is heading, why they need to go there, and how everyone will benefit if they achieve this goal collectively.
