Another spine practice joins the IDR fight

Advertisement

San Jose (Calif.) Neurospine is taking its fight over unpaid No Surprises Act arbitration awards to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 9th Circuit after a federal judge tossed its lawsuit against Microsoft and Anthem Blue Cross.

The practice, formally California Spine and Neurosurgery Institute, filed a notice of appeal Oct. 12, according to court documents. The 9th Circuit docketed the case Oct. 15.

The dispute stems from a spine surgery the out-of-network practice performed at an in-network facility on a patient covered by Microsoft’s self-funded employee health plan, for which Anthem Blue Cross processes claims. Anthem paid $1,110.59 on $82,005 in charges, according to the practice’s Oct. 27 mediation questionnaire filed with the 9th Circuit.

San Jose Neurospine won two independent dispute resolution proceedings, and the IDR entity awarded the practice an additional $71,888.85. The practice alleges Microsoft and Anthem neither paid nor challenged the awards. It sued in May, bringing claims under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act, the Federal Arbitration Act, the No Surprises Act and California state law.

On Sept. 23, the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California dismissed all 10 counts without leave to amend. The court held that the No Surprises Act does not create a private right of action to enforce IDR awards, that the Federal Arbitration Act can’t be used to confirm awards without a written arbitration agreement, that the practice lacked standing for its ERISA claims because the patient who assigned them suffered no concrete injury, and that the state-law claims improperly sidestep the law’s lack of a private right of action.

On appeal, the practice plans to argue the No Surprises Act authorizes courts to enforce binding IDR determinations and that it has standing as the patient’s assignee.

The case joins a growing stack of IDR enforcement appeals. The practice’s filing lists related appeals pending in the Second, Third, Seventh and Ninth circuits, including several brought by SpecialtyCare against Aetna, Cigna, UMR, Meritain Health and Health Care Service Corp. SpecialtyCare has also sued Anthem plans in Virginia and Colorado over unpaid awards.

Two federal appeals courts, the 5th and 2nd circuits, have already ruled that providers cannot sue to enforce IDR awards.

A spokesperson for Anthem Blue Cross told Becker’s in a statement that they agree with the dismissal of the case. 

“We believe the district court reached the correct decision in dismissing the claims in this case,” the statement read. “The ruling reinforces the established legal framework under the No Surprises Act, including Congress’s intent for disputes involving the enforcement of payment determinations issued by independent dispute resolution entities to be addressed through the mechanisms established by federal law. We remain confident in the court’s reasoning and will continue to defend our position.” 

Becker’s has reached out to Microsoft and will update with any additional information.

Advertisement

Next Up in Spine

Advertisement