Why spine surgery’s endoscopy boom could hit a wall

Advertisement

Patients want it. Surgeons are learning it. But James Mok, MD, worries that the economics of American spine surgery could prevent endoscopy from reaching its potential.

As chief of spinal endoscopy at Stanford (Calif.) University School of Medicine, Dr. Mok has watched interest grow in techniques designed to minimize surgical disruption and accelerate recovery. He trained in South Korea, where biportal endoscopy gained traction before attracting wider attention in the U.S., and spent nearly a decade performing primarily tubular minimally invasive procedures before adopting endoscopy.

Yet he sees a fundamental contradiction: The healthcare system often provides stronger financial incentives for more extensive operations than for the less invasive procedures patients increasingly seek.

“Endoscopic spine surgery has a totally different ideology,” he told Becker’s. “Do the smallest possible surgery that will work with the shortest recovery.” That philosophy, he believes, is gaining momentum faster than the payment system can accommodate it.

A movement driven by patients

Unlike many surgical innovations, Dr. Mok believes endoscopy’s growing popularity is largely patient-driven rather than industry-led.

Newer approaches, particularly biportal endoscopy, have expanded the technique’s versatility. Dr. Mok sees advantages in its visualization, with continuous irrigation helping maintain a clear operative field during decompression.

He also believes appropriately selected patients can experience less postoperative discomfort and faster recovery. Many of his endoscopic patients, he said, require little or no opioid medication after surgery.

Competition among spine practices is another factor, but Dr. Mok believes successful outcomes and patient referrals will ultimately drive adoption.

“Word of mouth is probably the most durable type of marketing,” he said.

A learning curve with no room for compromise

Even experienced minimally invasive surgeons face substantial challenges when transitioning to endoscopy. Dr. Mok knows firsthand. Despite his background in tubular surgery, mastering endoscopic techniques required considerable adjustment.

“Going through the learning curve mid-career, it’s not easy, particularly when complications are not acceptable,” he said.

Longer operating times may be unavoidable during training, but he draws a firm distinction between reduced efficiency and compromised care.

“I don’t think that a learning curve is any excuse for having worse outcomes,” he said.

Formal training opportunities remain limited, he added. Much of the movement has developed outside traditional academic pathways, leaving surgeons to seek education through specialized courses and mentorship. Dr. Mok believes professional societies and fellowship programs should treat endoscopy as an established surgical approach rather than a niche technique.

But even surgeons who master it face another obstacle.

When doing less pays less

Dr. Mok sees reimbursement as the greatest threat to widespread adoption. Endoscopic decompressions and microdiscectomies generally generate less reimbursement than spinal fusions, even as surgeons invest additional time in training and specialized equipment.

He pointed to longstanding concerns surrounding CPT code 62380, which describes certain endoscopic lumbar decompression procedures. In his view, the coding and reimbursement framework has failed to adequately recognize the work involved.

“Being told that your work relative value units are zero for this hard work you’re doing is a big deterrent for wider adoption,” he said.

The economics can be challenging in ASCs, where disposable instruments, specialized equipment and narrow margins complicate the financial case for endoscopy.

For employed surgeons, productivity-based compensation creates another consideration. Dr. Mok worries that these pressures could influence which procedures surgeons ultimately incorporate into their practices, regardless of the techniques they learned during training.

Why enthusiasm may not translate into adoption

Despite growing interest, Dr. Mok doubts endoscopy will become routine for most spine surgeons under current reimbursement conditions.

Even if more fellows receive training, he believes some will abandon the technique once they enter practice. 

“I don’t think that they will continue to use endoscopic spine surgery in the current reimbursement climate, regardless of whether you’re a hospital employee or an ASC owner,” he said.

Fusion presents a particular challenge. Although endoscopic approaches can be used in fusion procedures, Dr. Mok believes their recovery advantages may be less pronounced when instrumentation and other elements of a larger operation remain necessary.

Patients seeking endoscopy, he noted, are often hoping to avoid fusion altogether. The result is a disconnect between the philosophy behind endoscopy and the financial incentives shaping surgical practice.

What could change the equation

Dr. Mok believes wider adoption will depend on reimbursement reform and stronger educational support. He wants coding policies to better recognize endoscopic decompression and established device manufacturers to expand training opportunities, improve instruments and help reduce costs.

Emerging payment models that scrutinize resource-intensive procedures could eventually shift incentives toward less invasive approaches, he said. But he does not believe the specialty has reached that tipping point.

Still, his optimism extends beyond the technology itself. “I think our care would be better even if we just followed the philosophy of endoscopic spine surgery,” he said.

That philosophy emphasizes minimizing surgical disruption, carefully selecting procedures and prioritizing recovery. Whether endoscopy becomes a routine part of American spine care may depend less on how many surgeons learn it than on whether the healthcare system gives them a reason to keep using it.

At the Becker’s 32nd Annual Meeting: The Business and Operations of ASCs, taking place October 29-31 in Chicago, ASC leaders, surgeons and healthcare executives will explore strategies to drive growth, enhance operational performance, navigate reimbursement challenges and prepare for the future of ambulatory surgery. Apply for complimentary registration now.

Advertisement

Next Up in Spine

Advertisement