Spine surgery’s robot revolution has unfinished business

Advertisement

Spine surgery has spent years developing increasingly sophisticated ways to place implants. But Timothy Witham, MD, believes the next breakthrough will depend on what surgeons can accomplish beyond the hardware.

Dr. Witham has spent much of his career exploring the possibilities of surgical technology. After roughly two decades at Baltimore-based Johns Hopkins Medicine, he joined the University of Chicago Medicine, where he serves as professor of neurological surgery and chief of spine surgery. A pioneer in the use of augmented reality for spine procedures, he has published research exploring applications beyond instrumentation, including complex osteotomies and tumor removal.

Yet his experience has also made him acutely aware of what the technology cannot do.

Despite advances in robotics, navigation and augmented reality, Dr. Witham believes the specialty remains focused on perfecting a task surgeons can already perform effectively using conventional techniques. The greater opportunity, he argues, lies in making technology useful throughout an operation.

“All these technologies, to move the field forward and to do something novel and to make spine surgery easier and better, they have to do more,” he told Becker’s.

His vision is ambitious: augmented reality systems that help surgeons navigate delicate decompressions, plan complex procedures and access critical patient information without looking away from the operative field.

But he is equally candid about the obstacles. AR adoption has been slower than he anticipated, existing systems remain imperfect, and evidence that greater precision produces superior patient outcomes is still limited.

When precision isn’t enough

Freehand techniques, fluoroscopy, conventional navigation, robotics and augmented reality can all achieve accurate spinal instrumentation placement, Dr. Witham said. The best approach often depends on the surgeon’s experience.

“There is no way, in my opinion, where you can reliably place spinal instrumentation with 100% accuracy or precision,” he said.

He favors augmented reality because it allows surgeons to view navigational guidance while looking directly at the patient, rather than turning toward a separate monitor. It also preserves tactile feedback as surgeons work with instruments.

Those advantages have convinced him that AR may ultimately offer greater versatility than robotics, although he acknowledges that his preference does not establish its superiority.

“I am biased in thinking that I think AR is probably the best, but I still don’t think I can make that claim,” he said.

His enthusiasm also comes with a warning about technological dependence. Dr. Witham has abandoned AR guidance during procedures when the information did not appear reliable. Having spent much of his career placing instrumentation freehand, he considers the ability to recognize a malfunction and proceed without advanced guidance essential.

“I think you have to have a plan B,” he said.

He worries that surgeons who rely too heavily on technology risk surrendering some of the independent judgment needed when systems fail. His concern extends to robotics, although he emphasized that his assessment reflects personal experience and opinion.

The adoption and evidence problem

Despite his early involvement with augmented reality, Dr. Witham acknowledges that adoption has been slower than he expected. Robotics has gained considerable traction, while AR continues to face practical obstacles, including bulky headsets, workflow interruptions and capabilities that vary across platforms.

“I don’t think all the glitches have been completely worked out to make it as efficient and comprehensive as I think it will be one day,” he said.

He was also surprised that patients appeared more interested in robotic surgery than augmented reality, despite his belief that AR offers advantages that may be less obvious to patients. But the larger challenge is demonstrating clinical value. Dr. Witham said his team has published research suggesting AR-assisted procedures can achieve outcomes comparable to other methods.

Establishing that they consistently produce superior results remains difficult. “That’s the obligation of surgeons like myself who are proponents of the technology, to show that,” he said.

The calculation goes beyond accuracy. Hospitals and surgeons must consider patient safety, operative efficiency, workflow disruption and cost when deciding whether a technology represents a meaningful improvement.

For Dr. Witham, the strongest case for AR will emerge as it expands beyond instrumentation placement. 

He envisions systems that help surgeons navigate spinal decompressions while avoiding neural and vascular structures, plan osteotomies and remove tumors. In some procedures, he noted, placing the hardware represents only a small portion of the operation. The greater opportunity may lie in everything surrounding it.

A potential advantage for ASCs

Dr. Witham also sees an opportunity for augmented reality as more spine procedures move into ASCs.

He believes AR can offer a less expensive alternative to some robotic and conventional navigation systems, potentially making advanced guidance more accessible to outpatient facilities.

Fluoroscopy remains common in these settings, but it involves radiation exposure and the physical burden of wearing protective lead equipment. AR could offer another option, particularly as manufacturers develop lighter headsets and improve compatibility with different implants.

For now, he believes the technology must become more comfortable, efficient and comprehensive before its potential can be fully realized.

Beyond the headset

Dr. Witham envisions a future in which bulky headsets give way to lightweight surgical glasses capable of displaying nearly everything a surgeon needs during an operation. Preoperative CT and MRI scans, alignment measurements, planned osteotomies, instrumentation trajectories and other patient information could appear directly in the surgeon’s field of view.

Different companies are already developing elements of that vision, he said. The challenge is combining them into a practical, reliable platform.

Dr. Witham does not expect AR to replace every other approach. He sees it as part of a broader technological evolution, potentially working alongside robotics and other systems. “I think it’s the most versatile technology right now, in terms of moving forward in the future,” he said.

His vision is not one in which technology takes greater control of surgery, but one in which surgeons have more information and capabilities without losing their focus on the patient.

After years of competing to place hardware more precisely, the next test for spine surgery technology may be whether it can help surgeons do everything else better.

At the Becker’s 32nd Annual Meeting: The Business and Operations of ASCs, taking place October 29-31 in Chicago, ASC leaders, surgeons and healthcare executives will explore strategies to drive growth, enhance operational performance, navigate reimbursement challenges and prepare for the future of ambulatory surgery. Apply for complimentary registration now.

Advertisement

Next Up in Spine

Advertisement