Orthopedic training has spent decades moving toward specialization. Sports medicine. Adult reconstruction. Hand. Foot and ankle. Spine. Surgeons increasingly build careers around narrower areas of expertise, often concentrating in large health systems and metropolitan markets.
Charles Holliday, MD, had every opportunity to follow that path. He completed his orthopedic surgery residency at Mayo Clinic in Rochester, Minn., then pursued a sports medicine fellowship at the University of Utah in Salt Lake City, where he helped care for professional athletes as an assistant team physician for the NBA’s Utah Jazz and the NHL’s Utah Mammoth.
Then he chose something different. Dr. Holliday joined Heartland Orthopedic Specialists in Alexandria, Minn., where his practice stretches across much of orthopedics: sports injuries, cartilage restoration, fracture care and joint replacement.
The breadth is intentional. “There are so many things to love in orthopedics,” Dr. Holliday told Becker’s. “In the past, everyone was a generalist, and now people are becoming more and more hyperspecialized.”
At the beginning of his career, Dr. Holliday is betting there is still value in going the other direction.
What specialization can leave behind
Dr. Holliday did not choose a broad practice because he wanted to leave his fellowship training behind. He chose it partly because he wanted to use more of what he had learned.
At Mayo Clinic, he trained in a residency with significant exposure to joint replacement. At Utah, he added specialized sports medicine training. A practice limited exclusively to sports medicine would have meant giving up part of that experience.
“I didn’t want to pass that up to hyperfocus on sports medicine only,” he said. The result is a practice that can look very different depending on the patient walking through the door.
A younger athlete with a major knee injury may need ligament reconstruction or cartilage restoration aimed at preserving the native joint for decades. An older patient with advanced arthritis may need a hip, knee or shoulder replacement to regain function.
Dr. Holliday finds value in both. On the sports medicine side, he is particularly interested in intervening early enough to change the trajectory of an injured joint.
“You can help restore the joint, bring it back to its native anatomy and give patients a knee, hip or shoulder that could last the rest of their lives,” he said.
Joint replacement offers a different kind of opportunity. “Patients do so well, and it can be such a life-changing procedure,” he said. Rather than choosing between those ends of orthopedic care, he wanted a career that included both.
The appeal of practicing smaller
Where Dr. Holliday chose to build that career matters, too. After training at major academic centers, he joined an established regional orthopedic group in Alexandria, a central Minnesota community far removed from the scale of the institutions where he trained.
For Dr. Holliday, that was part of the appeal.
“You really get to know your patients and the team you’re working with,” he said. “I enjoy that community experience.”
The difference is not only professional. In a smaller community, he sees the possibility of knowing where his patients fit beyond the exam room, because he lives there, too. “That’s a part of this job that you don’t see in the bigger cities,” he said.
Heartland also offered something increasingly central to how younger physicians think about career decisions: the ability to build a demanding surgical practice without allowing it to consume everything around it.
Dr. Holliday calls it “work-life integration.”
“I can do my best at work to take care of the people in my community, but also enjoy the place I live,” he said. For him, that means time with his family and access to the outdoors alongside a surgical career. He said the practice’s schedule and culture made that balance seem sustainable.
“I don’t have to sacrifice as much on my personal side to still do a great job taking care of patients,” he said.
Bringing specialized care to a regional market
There is another side to the decision. The expertise concentrated at major training institutions does not necessarily have to stay there. Dr. Holliday sees his move as an opportunity to bring techniques and experience from Mayo and Utah into a smaller community while remaining broad enough to meet its orthopedic needs.
That is particularly relevant in joint replacement. “I learned a lot about joint replacement and want to use that expertise to help patients here in this rural community,” he said.
It is a model that complicates the usual choice between specialist and generalist. Dr. Holliday remains fellowship trained in sports medicine. But instead of allowing that subspecialty to define the boundaries of his practice, he sees it as expertise he can layer onto a broader orthopedic foundation.
The same philosophy shapes what he is watching next. Joint preservation is one of the areas he believes could change substantially as biologic therapies, grafts and repair techniques improve. Joint replacements can produce excellent outcomes, he said, but they remain replacements.
“Nothing’s quite the same as the joints we were born with,” Dr. Holliday said. “Preserving those the best we can is a really special gift.”
He is already seeing that evolution in areas such as rotator cuff repair and cartilage restoration, where surgeons can use grafts and biologic augmentation in an effort to improve healing or restore damaged tissue.
“There’s going to be more and more opportunity to restore cartilage as opposed to replacing it when we can,” he said.
The career he wants 20 years from now
For all the technology Dr. Holliday expects to change during his career, his definition of success is notably low-tech. He wants the patients he treats now to still be his patients decades from now.
At 10, 15 or 20 years, some may return because they are still doing well. Others may come back because their condition has changed and they need his help again. Either outcome would mean he stayed long enough to see what happened after the operation, rehabilitation and immediate recovery were over.
“Having longstanding relationships with patients and seeing how the work I’ve done impacts their lives will be the most rewarding thing,” he said.
It is an unusually long horizon for a surgeon just beginning practice. But it also explains much of what brought Dr. Holliday to Alexandria: an established group, a broad scope of practice and a community where the people he treats today may still be walking through his door decades from now.
For a surgeon trained in an era of ever-narrower specialization, that continuity may be its own kind of expertise.
At the Becker’s 32nd Annual Meeting: The Business and Operations of ASCs, taking place October 29-31 in Chicago, ASC leaders, surgeons and healthcare executives will explore strategies to drive growth, enhance operational performance, navigate reimbursement challenges and prepare for the future of ambulatory surgery. Apply for complimentary registration now.
